Brookline Buyers Paid $468,000 Over Ask at 38 Fuller Street, and $1,076 a Square Foot
38 Fuller Street closed September 25 at $4,368,000 against a $3,900,000 list price. The price breakdown, $1,076 per square foot and how it compares with Brookline's other closings.
On September 25, 2026, 38 Fuller Street in Brookline (02446) closed at $4,368,000, 12% over its $3.9M list price after 8 days on market. See the $1,076/sqft math, a 55% premium to assessment, and how it compares with Brookline's recent comps.
Recently Sold Spotlight: 38 Fuller Street, Brookline
Closed: September 25, 2026 at $4,368,000
List price: $3,900,000
Over ask: $468,000 (+12.0%)
Price per square foot: $1,076
Days on market (Zillow): 8
Tax-assessed value on record: $2,816,800
Zillow Zestimate: $3,825,100
Listing brokerage: Gibson Sotheby's International Realty
Source: Zillow sold-listing data via the maxcopell Apify actor (BMAS sales file, October 3, 2026 snapshot) and the MLS PIN listing (#73566334) as republished by IDX sites.
⚡Eight days, $468,000 of extra money
On a quiet Coolidge Corner side street, a 1900 Colonial hit the market at $3,900,000 and sold in eight days for $4,368,000. That is $468,000, or 12.0%, over the asking price, and it works out to $1,076 per square foot for 4,060 square feet of house.
For context, Brookline is not a town where a $4 million-plus price tag is routine. Of the seven Brookline single-family closings in our September sales file, only two cleared $4 million, and 38 Fuller Street is one of them. The other six closed between $1.85 million and $4.65 million, with a median of $2,537,500. The Fuller Street buyer paid roughly 72% more than that median.
🔍The forensic breakdown
| Metric | 38 Fuller St | Reference point | Gap |
|---|---|---|---|
Sold vs. list | $4,368,000 | $3,900,000 list | +12.0% (+$468,000) |
Sold vs. Zestimate | $4,368,000 | $3,825,100 | +14.2% |
Sold vs. tax assessment | $4,368,000 | $2,816,800 | +55.1% |
Price per sq ft | $1,076 | $592 (six other Brookline closings) | +82% |
Price per sq ft of lot | $623 | 7,016 sq ft lot (0.16 acre) | — |
Days on market | 8 | Zillow count | — |
Read the table top to bottom and the pattern is a market that did not wait for the usual valuation signals. The house closed 14% above Zillow's own estimate and 55% above the town's assessed value. Assessments are set on a delay, so a gap is expected, but it is a useful reminder that neither number is a ceiling when a scarce property shows up.
🏡What the buyer got for the money
The listing markets a renovated Colonial on four levels with six bedrooms and about 4.5 baths (Zillow records five). Details from the listing include a white quartz kitchen, new tiled bathrooms, new Lennox HVAC systems, a new hot water tank, a rubber roof and a refurbished slate roof, a custom sauna and two sets of washers and dryers.
The parking and outbuilding story is the unusual part for Coolidge Corner. The listing describes a four-car garage plus three non-tandem spaces and a 90-foot driveway, a fenced yard with a fire pit, and a carriage house with what the agent calls 900 square feet of by-right accessory-dwelling potential. There is also a private-entry in-law or office suite and a stated 3,000 square feet of expansion potential on a lot in the T5 zone. Those are the listing's marketing claims. Buyers should verify zoning and permitting directly with the Town of Brookline before counting on any of them.
We do not know how many offers the house drew, what the buyer's financing looked like, or whether the sale included concessions, because none of that is in the public listing record. What we can say is that the final price, not the ask, is what the market actually set.
📐How it stacks up against Brookline's other closings
| Address | Sold | Price | Sq ft | $/sq ft | Beds |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
38 Fuller St | Sep 25, 2026 | $4,368,000 | 4,060 | $1,076 | 6 |
178 Ivy St | Sep 10, 2026 | $4,650,000 | 3,560 | $1,306 | 4 |
191 Newton St | Sep 14, 2026 | $3,335,000 | 4,082 | $817 | 4 |
171 Shaw Rd | Sep 30, 2026 | $2,575,000 | 4,585 | $562 | 5 |
2 Mason Ter | Sep 24, 2026 | $2,500,000 | 5,748 | $435 | 6 |
142 Beverly Rd | Sep 15, 2026 | $1,940,000 | 3,123 | $621 | 4 |
76 Goodnough Rd | Sep 3, 2026 | $1,850,000 | 3,475 | $532 | 4 |
Subscribe to Market Pulse
Get weekly Boston suburban real estate insights delivered to your inbox.
Fuller Street vs. Brookline's recent comps
The contrast with 2 Mason Terrace is telling: also six bedrooms, but 5,748 square feet and $435 per square foot. In Brookline, location and lot-level extras, not bedroom count, drive the premium.
📈What this sale signals about Brookline
Three takeaways. First, a renovated, move-in-ready house in the Coolidge Corner area cleared well above ask. A 12% premium in eight days says buyer demand for the right property has not gone away.
Second, the price per square foot spread inside one town is enormous. The same September file runs from $435 to $1,306 per square foot. Anyone benchmarking a Brookline address against a town-wide average is comparing very different things; the comp set has to be built street by street.
Third, list price is a strategy, not a prediction. A $3.9 million ask drew a $4.37 million result. Sellers and agents in Brookline appear to be pricing to attract a crowd, and buyers who bid to the list price on a property like this are likely bidding for second place.
What the data does and does not tell us
🔍 See every Brookline sold comp
Browse Brookline's recent closings with price, $/sqft, lot size and assessed value, then check how any address stacks up against the town.
View Brookline Sold Comps🧭 Run any address through RAAM
Paste an address and see the RAAM analysis against real sold comps in the same town, including whether the ask is realistic.
Open the Property AnalyzerGet the next sold-listing teardown first
Explore the Brookline town profile, sold-comp tools and RAAM analyzer at bmas.dwellchecker.app.
Subscribe to the weekly Market Pulse
One prestige-town sold listing, taken apart every Thursday, plus the week's Greater Boston market read.
Weekly updates • No spam • Unsubscribe anytime
Need Custom Analysis?
Want deeper insights for a specific property or neighborhood? Get a custom research report tailored to your needs—from individual property analysis to comprehensive market overviews.
Request Custom Analysis