Belmont02478135 Marsh StreetMarsh StRecently SoldSold SpotlightPrice ReductionsLuxury HomesDays on MarketPrice Per Square FootSold CompsPrestige TownsMarket AnalysisBelmont Real Estate

Listed at $6.9 Million, Sold for $4 Million: The 896-Day Price Slide at 135 Marsh Street, Belmont

135 Marsh Street closed October 13 at $4,000,000: $2.9 million under its first ask, three listing runs, five price moves and a $499,000 drop after the contract. The full price ladder and Belmont comps.

October 29, 2026
7 min read
Boston Property Navigator Research Team•Market Analysis

On October 13, 2026, 135 Marsh Street in Belmont (02478) closed at $4,000,000 for an 8,069 sqft home on 1.38 acres, 42% below its $6,900,000 April 2024 ask. See the full price ladder, $496/sqft versus Belmont's $569 comp median, and what it signals for Belmont's luxury market.

📉

Recently Sold Spotlight: 135 Marsh Street, Belmont

A 8,069-square-foot custom home on 1.38 acres at 135 Marsh Street, Belmont, MA 02478 (built 1995).

Closed: October 13, 2026 at $4,000,000
First asking price (April 30, 2024): $6,900,000
Drop from first ask: 42% ($2.9 million)
Price per square foot: $496 (asked $855 at launch)
Tax-assessed value on record (2025): $6,557,000
Zillow Zestimate: $4,137,200
Listing brokerage: Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Commonwealth Real Estate

Source: Zillow sold-listing and MLS PIN price-history data via the maxcopell Apify actors, cross-checked against BMAS's weekly sales files.
$4,000,000
135 Marsh St Sold Price
Closed October 13, 2026
-42%
Below First Ask
$6,900,000 on April 30, 2024
896 days
Time on the Market
First listing to closing, across three listing cycles
$496
Price Per Square Foot
vs. $569 Belmont median for recent $1.8M+ closings

✂️The $2.9 million haircut

On April 30, 2024, 135 Marsh Street in Belmont hit the market at $6,900,000. On October 13, 2026, it closed at $4,000,000. That is a $2.9 million, 42% drop from the first ask, and it took 896 days and three separate listing runs to get there.

Belmont does not usually make headlines for this kind of thing. It is one of Greater Boston's most sought-after commuter suburbs, and this month alone four other Belmont houses sold between $2.25 million and $2.8 million, a couple of them within days of listing, per Zillow. Marsh Street is the exception that explains the rule: in a market where well-priced houses fly, a house priced for a market that no longer exists sits.

🪜The price ladder, rung by rung

Here is the MLS PIN record for the property, in order. Every figure below comes from the listing history, not from our estimates.

DateEventPrice$/sqftChange

Apr 30, 2024

Listed

$6,900,000

$855

—

Sep 25, 2024

Price cut

$6,595,000

$817

-4.4%

Feb 17, 2025

Listing removed

$6,595,000

$817

—

Apr 30, 2025

Relisted

$6,400,000

$793

-3.0% vs. last ask

Jul 21, 2025

Price cut

$5,895,000

$731

-7.9%

Sep 23, 2025

Price cut

$5,395,000

$669

-8.5%

Mar 27, 2026

Removed, then relisted

$4,775,000

$592

-11.5%

Jun 20, 2026

Price cut

$4,499,000

$558

-5.8%

Aug 28, 2026

Contingent

$4,499,000

$558

—

Sep 11, 2026

Pending

$4,499,000

$558

—

Oct 13, 2026

Sold

$4,000,000

$496

-11.1% vs. last ask

Read the ladder top to bottom and the story is a seller slowly accepting a new price level. The first listing opened at $6.9 million and shed about $305,000 in five months. The second run started a point lower and took two cuts of roughly $500,000 each. The third began at $4,775,000, already $2.1 million under the original ask, and still needed a cut before a buyer showed up.

Then comes the part the listing history makes hard to ignore. The house went contingent on August 28 at $4,499,000 and pending on September 11. It closed $499,000 lower, at $4,000,000. The public record does not say why. A reduction between contract and closing is commonly the sign of a renegotiation after inspections or an appraisal, but that is our inference, not something the data confirms.

🏡What the buyer actually bought

The listing describes a custom-designed home on a lot of more than 60,000 square feet, about nine miles from Boston, with two wings set at a 30-degree angle around gardens and courtyards. One wing holds a primary suite with a circular study; the other has a chef's kitchen, a walk-in pantry, a wet bar and a three-car garage. Zillow's record shows 8,069 square feet, a 1995 build and 1.38 acres.

That is a lot of house and a lot of land in Belmont, and it is the combination that makes the price hard to benchmark. At $4,000,000 the buyer paid $496 per square foot. At the original ask the number would have been $855.

📐How it compares with Belmont's other big closings

AddressSoldPriceSqft$/sqftLot (acres)

135 Marsh St

Oct 13, 2026

$4,000,000

8,069

$496

1.38

70 Birch Hill Rd

Oct 8, 2026

$2,802,740

6,936

$404

0.42

12 Kilburn Rd

Oct 28, 2026

$2,769,511

4,325

$640

0.36

28 Homer Rd

Oct 14, 2026

$2,694,000

4,734

$569

0.36

9 Lantern Rd

Oct 28, 2026

$2,250,000

3,955

$569

0.46

156 Common St

Sep 30, 2026

$2,450,000

2,823

$868

0.25

Subscribe to Market Pulse

Get weekly Boston suburban real estate insights delivered to your inbox.

📊

How this compares to Belmont's recent comps

Across the seven Belmont closings above $1.8 million that we pulled since September 29, the median price per square foot is $569. Marsh Street at $496 sits 13% below that median, and its $4.0 million price is 1.4x the next-highest Belmont sale in the set (70 Birch Hill Rd at $2.8 million). The only closing with a lower per-foot price is Birch Hill, the closest in size (6,936 sqft), at $404.

The pattern is familiar from our other prestige-town teardowns: the biggest houses trade at the steepest per-foot discount, because the pool of buyers who can write a $4 million check shrinks fast as the price climbs.

🧮The assessor and the algorithm disagree with the seller's history

Belmont's assessor carried the property at $6,557,000 for 2025, with a tax bill of $74,684, up 17% in a year. The house sold for 61% of that figure. Anyone appealing an assessment in Belmont will notice that gap.

Zillow's Zestimate, $4,137,200, landed within 3.3% of the final price. The algorithm had already priced the house where the market eventually did, long before the third relisting. The last sale in public records before this one is a $725,000 transfer in June 1994, a year before the house's 1995 build date, so today's price is about 5.5x that figure.

🔭What the sale signals about Belmont

Three takeaways. First, Belmont's market is bifurcated: homes in the $2.2 to $2.8 million band closed quickly this month, while a house that opened at $6.9 million needed 896 days. Price discipline, not location, decided the outcome.

Second, the ceiling is lower than the ask history suggested. Nearly two years of asks above $5 million did not produce a buyer; a deal first came together at $4.499 million, and the closing price was lower still. That is useful signal for owners of other Belmont estates thinking about a $5 million-plus listing.

Third, patient buyers still win in the luxury tier. A buyer who tracked this listing from the start would have watched the price fall by $2.9 million. The lesson is not to wait for every house to drop that far, but to read the price history before you make an offer.

⚠️

What the data does and does not tell us

Listing dates, prices and agent details come from MLS PIN history as republished by Zillow. We do not know the reason for the removals, the seller's motivation, or why the closing price fell $499,000 after the contract. Zillow's own days-on-market counter differs from the MLS timeline because of the relistings, so we use MLS dates throughout. Lot size is as recorded by Zillow.

🔍 See every Belmont sold comp

Browse Belmont's recent closings with price, $/sqft, lot size and assessed value, then check how any address stacks up against the town.

View Belmont Sold Comps

🧭 Run any address through RAAM

Paste an address and see the RAAM analysis against real sold comps in the same town, including whether the ask is realistic.

Open the Property Analyzer
📨

Get the next sold-listing teardown first

Every Thursday we profile a fresh recently-sold listing in one of Greater Boston's most prestigious towns. Subscribe to the blog and the weekly Market Pulse newsletter so the next one lands in your inbox before it hits the feed.

Explore the Belmont town profile, sold-comp tools and RAAM analyzer at bmas.dwellchecker.app.
Newsletter

Subscribe to the weekly Market Pulse

One prestige-town sold listing, taken apart every Thursday, plus the week's Greater Boston market read.

Weekly updates • No spam • Unsubscribe anytime

Need Custom Analysis?

Want deeper insights for a specific property or neighborhood? Get a custom research report tailored to your needs—from individual property analysis to comprehensive market overviews.

Request Custom Analysis
Market Pulse

Boston suburban intel, every Friday

Weekly market analysis, hidden red flags, and strategic buyer intelligence — delivered straight to your inbox.

Weekly updates • No spam • Unsubscribe anytime

Related Posts

Market reportBrookline02446

Brookline Buyers Paid $468,000 Over Ask at 38 Fuller Street, and $1,076 a Square Foot

38 Fuller Street closed September 25 at $4,368,000 against a $3,900,000 list price. The price breakdown, $1,076 per square foot and how it compares with Brookline's other closings.

On September 25, 2026, 38 Fuller Street in Brookline (02446) closed at $4,368,000, 12% over its $3.9M list price after 8 days on market. See the $1,076/sqft math, a 55% premium to assessment, and how it compares with Brookline's recent comps.

November 12, 2026
7 min
Market reportSherborn01770

25 Acres, 10,406 Square Feet, $2.8 Million: Inside the Sherborn Sale at 75 Washington Street

75 Washington Street closed August 24 at $2,800,000: $269 per square foot, about $109,700 per acre, and a Zestimate that missed by just $200. Sherborn's big-house discount, explained with real comps.

On August 24, 2026, 75 Washington Street in Sherborn (01770) closed at $2,800,000 for a 10,406 sqft home on 25.53 acres: $269/sqft, 1.9x the town's recent median. See how it compares with 4 Green Lane at $216/sqft, 7 Goulding Street East and other Sherborn sold comps.

October 15, 2026
6 min
Market reportWellesley02482

Four Wellesley Homes, $22.7 Million, 16 Days: Inside the $6.3M Sale at 222 Grove Street

222 Grove Street closed September 18 at $6,300,000, 1.8x Wellesley's recent median, as part of a four-sale, $22.7 million run in sixteen days. Zillow has no Zestimate for it, and it sold at 3.1x its assessed value.

On September 18, 2026, 222 Grove Street in Wellesley closed at $6,300,000 ($778/sqft, 8,093 sqft, 1.233 acres), the top of four Wellesley sales between $5.1M and $6.3M in just 16 days. See how it compares to Wellesley's $3.495M recent median, what the assessment gap says, and where the market has a hollow middle.

October 8, 2026
6 min
135 Marsh St Belmont MA Sold $4,000,000 — 42% Below $6.9M Ask After 896 Days (2026) | Boston Market Pulse